Affichage des articles dont le libellé est chromosome fusion. Afficher tous les articles
Affichage des articles dont le libellé est chromosome fusion. Afficher tous les articles

jeudi 11 juin 2009

Chromosome numbers



series and tinyurl to this one --- see comments

Why is this a problem for evolution? Genes mutate. In each population, sometimes the mutation, sometimes the unmutated gene and sometimes both prevail. If a population splits in two, they will mutate into different ways. If enough genes are different, at last the populations will be genetically too different for mating to occur with offspring viable and fertile. They are two different species.

This link is to an article - in fulltext - dealing with an experiment where speciations is seen as having been directly observed. Read their definitions carefully. "Even though behaviorally isolated species ..." "behaviorally isolated" - well that would make different human cultures count as different species too.

SO WHAT IS THE PROBLEM?

CHROMOSOMES

Genes bunch in chromosomes, and chromosomes are counted in whole numbers. And the number of chromosomes is fairly fixed, and yet mammals have different numbers of chromosomes.

In most species, mammal or not, chromosomes are diploid (Greek for twofold, meaning all of the chromosomes) in the cells making up a single body, haploid (Greek for simple, meaning in all of the chromosomes) in sex cells. Triploid (Greek for threefold, meaning in all of the chromosomes) individuals occur in plants, fish, lizards, birds, they are infertile or selffertilising females, both ways are roads out of sexual reproduction and therefore evolution as usually understood.

Diploid chromosome setups mean that chromosomes go in pairs that hang together at the centromere and branch off to telomeres. Centromeres (middle pieces) and Telomeres (end pieces) are like full stops in genetic information. It is DNA bundled too tight for readability. But they are essential for the RNA-readings of the arms - an arm is whatever part of a chromosome is between one Centromere and one Telomere. Chromosomes have one centromere and two telomeres, except (if I recall correctly) Y-chromosomes that have only two telomeres, one of which counts as centromere because bundling with such of the X-chromosome.

Less chromosomes More chromosomes
Normally for diploid beings:

Sex cells forming halve the number of chromosomes into only one for each pair.

Sex cells meeting and forming new individuals double the number of the sex cell chromosomes, getting back to normal.

Not Normally for diploid beings:
  • Haplosomy (onefold in one single pair) going on to asomy (none in that pair)? Asomy means total lack of one chromosome and means non-viability of embryon. So haplosomy is a non-way. Unless, which is not very likely, all the vital information of a chromosome had been transferred to chromosomes of another pair. In mankind, Y-chromosome haplosomy is not viable, but X-chromosome haplosomy gives infertile or less fertile women. But they are same pair, XX a normal woman, XY a normal man.
  • Robertsonian chromosome fusion, is this how it works?


















    Have I proven too much?

    Mice go in different chromosome numbers, and they seem to be yet one species.

    Okapi may have one or two chromosome pairs or even a pair and a half, for same parts of genome.

  • Chromosome fission - as complex as fusion (study diagrams and handwritten text on image left), plus where does the new centromere or the new telomeres come from?
(P Z Myers claims new centromere comes from locus duplication - but that does not explain new telomere on the intra-centromere side of each split)
  • Trisomy (three chromsomes in one single pair) - means handicap, sometimes to fertility (in sex chromosomes) sometimes to other chromosomes. But a trisomy, even if extended after a generation to tetrasomy, does not mean two pairs where there was one, only four chromosomes to a pair, and that is handicap.
  • Polyploidy: triploidy see above. Tetraploid and octoploid individuals occur in amphibians and plants - that are typically greater or stronger or twice as complex as diploid samples. Mammals are neither amphibians nor plants.

    Even if they could be polyploid, which seems not to be the case, that would not open the way for new pairs forming. Each four chromosomes are the four chromosomes of a pair, not the two by two chromosomes of two pairs.


Theories should in principle be falsifiable. If evolution is a theory, chromosome numbers - as well as other similar creationist arguments - are not theories, but falsifications of this theory.

I think chromosome numbers is such a difficulty (if not downright disproof) that that is why Scientists are very shy about putting on the web articles for free about this subject. On my comments to Non-replies I have been looking for such using a scholar google. Time after time I have only got to the abstract of an article that is readable for paying subscribers only. See list at end of comments.



Hans-Georg Lundahl
en déptnt13 ou 84
30 May/11 June AD 2009

PS, A list of different chromosome numbers from a creationist site:

The Evolution of Species by Means of Increasing Number of Chromosomes
-or-
The Preservation of Complex Life Forms in the Struggle for Life

-By Dr. Kent Hovind-

Number of Chromosomes:

  • Fern 480 The ultimate goal.

  • White Ash 138

  • Carp 100

  • Goldfish 94

  • Sweet Potato 90
  • Turkey 82

    • Chicken 78

    • Dog 78

    • Duck 78 Identical Triplets!

  • Horse 64

  • Cow 60

  • Silkworm 56

  • Cotton 52

  • Amoeba 50

    • Chimp 48

    • Tobacco 48 Identical Twins!

  • Human 46

  • Bat 44

  • Wheat 42

  • Soybean 40


  • Cat 38

  • Starfish 36

  • Apple 34

    • Alligator 32

    • Onion 32 Identical Twins!

  • Frog 26

    • Opossum 22

    • Redwood 22

    • Kidney Bean 22 Identical Triplets!

    • Corn 20

    • Marijuana 20

    • Carrot 20 Identical Triplets!

  • Lettuce 18

  • Honeybee 16

  • Garden Pea 14

    • House Fly 12

    • Tomato 12 Identical Twins!

  • Fruit Fly 8

  • Penicillium 2


Source: DrDino/Kent Hovind - after reading which I searched in Talkorigins.org and got this. Which is where my argument comes from.

Credits to user Jon for giving me the opportunity to refind it.

mardi 28 avril 2009

René Le Gal ... L'ADN en question(s) - rélévance pour le débat créationniste/évolutionniste et Benoît XVI

Admettons d'abord:

J'ai pas lu tout le livre. J'ai vérifié en perlisant les rubriques des chapitres, qu'il n'y avait pas de chapitre consacré à la question de la diversité des nombres des chromosomes chez les mammifères. Ce que me parait le plus grand problème pour les évolutionnistes. Qu'un chimpanzee a 48 chromosomes et un homme 46, ce n'est pas tellement le problème. L'homme pourrait théoriquement avoir eu deux paires de chromosomes conflatés.

Attention: ce n'est pas du tout sur que ce soit passé ainsi. A part le nombre reduit il y a entre chimpanzee et homme tellement des différences, qu'il serait hazardeux d'affirmer l'identité à part quelque remaniements. Ce site ci ne donne pas les différences locales, à nombre de milliers ou dixaines de milliers.

Mais fusion, c'est une chose, augmenter le nombre des chromosomes c'est une autre. Télomères pourraient être conflatés en un centromère (fusion Richardsonienne) mais d'où viennent les nouveaux centromères en cas de fission chromosomique? Par hypothèse, les télomères démeurent télomères dans ce cas là. C'est le problème où conduit le scénario selon lequelle 2n=48 chez les premiers mammifères.

C'est donc uniquement pour vérifier si Le Gal avait apporté une reponse ou une tentative échouée de reponse (ce que m'aurait donné un plaisir malin) que j'ai ouvert son livre. Voici maintenant une chose que j'y trouve:

Je ne crois pas au paradis. En revanche, je sais que l'enfer existe. ... C'est l'enfer au quottidien des exclus, des pauvres, des sans-abri, des sans-papier, des handicapés, des malades, des femmes violées, mal traitées, de toutes les victimes de la violence d'autres hommes.


Remarque: Je suis sans-abri. Ce n'est pas un enfer. Ce matin j'avais occasion de passer par un endroit où l'année passée on m'avait donné des khakis, mais plein. Par gentillesse ils m'ont ajouté le café de ce matin. Non, l'existence quotidienne des sans-abris n'est pas un enfer. Grace à Dieu. Si je voudrais la finir? Dépend de ce que j'aurai en retour.

Après, il laisse entendre que la religion, par conséquent le concepte d'une création récente de l'homme, soient là pour donner un espoir de paradis dans l'au-delà aux misérables. Un truc "vieux comme le monde".

Faux.

L'espoir d'arriver au paradis en masse, simplement en restant gentil, n'est pas plus vieux que le christianisme.

Moïse parlait pas de paradis à atteindre après la mort, au moins pas ouvertement. Même la résurrection des morts est plutôt insinuée indirectement que clairement dite. Pour beaucoup des païens, le seul bonheur possible pour les morts étaient les sacrifices aux défunts. Platon, les Stoïciens et Bouddha, et Zoroastre aussi, parlaient d'un paradis dans l'au-delà, mais sous conditions pas trop populaires. Les égyptiens étaient plus proche, mais même pour eux les différences sociales persistaient à l'au-delà. La résignation sociale était due à une résignation plus profonde - qu'il avait toujours été ainsi, que même l'au-delà fera pas grande différence. Erreur partagé par Le Gal.

Ou alors le monde s'est renouvelé, et le monde et le nouvel espoir ont un même age de 2000 ans.

Non plus il n'est pas vrai que le christianisme prone une passivité sociale absolue. Tellement des vierges ont sacrifié leurs vies pour un amour et un espoir qui paraient foux à la société. Si la fille à maison n'est plus l'esclave absolue de son père, c'est du à l'espoir d'un au-delà, c'est du à sainte Cécile et sainte Barbe, mais aussi à sainte Géneviève et sainte Claire.

Ça a quel rapprt avec l'ADN? Aucun, biensur. Et Le Gal le sait. il s'est permi une diatribe anticléricale, totalement hors sujet, j'y repond. Mais il retourne à l'ADN, et je le suis. Rien du nombre de chromosomes des mammifères, biensur, mais quand même de l'ADN. Et la religion, catholique (ou pas tellement), en plus.

Le père Teilhard de Chardin écrivait en 1950, peu de temps avant de mourir, que "la vie est la forme que prend la matière à un certain niveau de complexité". Pouvait-on mieux résumer la pensée profonde - le dogme? - de la biologie moderne que par cette formule concise et précise d'un religieux, d'un jésuite?


Ah, la biologie moderne a ses dogmes ou pensées profondes? Des pensées au-delà des simples données observées? Merci pour l'aveu, alors! Et Teilhard de Chardin formule les dogmes de ... pas le christianisme, mais la biologie moderne? Merci pour l'observation!

Pour lui, il n'y avait pas d'opposition entre la foi catholique et la science. Le tout est de savoir où l'on place Dieu. Il est la conscience suprême, spirituelle, mais il n'est, pour le chercheur jésuite, ni à l'origine de la terre ni à celle de la vie. C'est, évidemment, encore trop pour les athées, mais cette conception de la foi a au moins le mérite de sauver les apparences de la réflexion, d'accepter les connaissances qui dérangent, de ne pas bafouer la conscience humaine.


Résumons en mes mots: Teilhard de Chardin, ou son école à l'état pure s'il y en a encore, ne croit pas que Dieu eusse créé, ni la terre, ni la vie. Ça c'est sauver les apparences de la réflexion. Ah bon, ceux qui croient que Dieu a bien créé les deux et l'homme en plus ne reflechissent pas, alors? Le dogme de "la biologie moderne" est alors "la conscience humaine" à ne pas surtout bafouer? Je ne crois pas avoir surinterprété le texte.

Il y en a plein d'hommes à être en désaccord avec ça, même par rapport purement de leur conscience humaine et j'en fais parti. Pour repondre dans la même veine de socio-indignation par rapport à un dogme qu'utilise Le Gal: le christianisme ne rend pas ses fidèles suffisamment remodèlables pour le goût de certains riches ou téchnocrates qui voudraient que les chantiers tournent 24/24 et 7/7, détruisant ainsi les heures du calme pour les voisins avec le biorhytme des équipiers de nuit, tout avec le repos du dimanche. Alors ils veulent le remplacer.

Le mieux, c'est nier Dieu. Le mieux pour nier Dieu, c'est prétendre qu'il y a une autre explication qui marche parfaitement pour expliquer l'homme, la vie, la terre et l'univers. Tant pis s'il faut prétendre que c'est par une lutte sans répit pour l'existence qu'évolue le crossoptérygien à l'amphibien, l'amphibien au reptile, et ensuite des reptile juste les oiseaux et les mammifères, les animaux avec piété, compassion et tendresse. Ou tant mieux, de leur point de vue, car alors on peut dire aux ouvriers "la vie est dure, il faut lutter pour l'existence". Et les banques peuvent le dire à ceux qui refusent d'imposer cette lutte à leurs ouvriers.

Une époque, on n'était pas encore prets à nier Dieu, c'était avant la révolution industrielle. Avant les révolutions de France et les guerres Napoléoniennes. Pendant les lumières il y avait un ou deux à nier Dieu directement et ouvertement. Didérot et d'Alembert. Ils prétendaient par là justifier la jouissance sans freins, chose de toute façon inaccessible pour la masse. Leur fruit moral est un marquis un peu trop connu: de Sade.

Avant cette négation, au moins on niait que Dieu aie créé l'homme au centre de sa création. D'où l'héliocentrisme, la prétence que la terre soit centré autour du soleil. Hypothèse encore pas prouvée, mais qui fonctionne comme un passe-partout contre le dogme catholique, et sape en même temps la confiance qu'a normalement l'homme dans ses sens. Ils sont supplémentés par mauvaise logique:

Rappelez-vous : tous les êtres vivants, des bactéries les plus rudimentaires aux animaux les plus évolués et à l'homme, depuis les virus jusqu'aux végétaux, possèdent le même ADN, avec le même alphabet, le même code. Comment peut-on nier, dans ces conditions, la parenté entre tous les vivants de cette planète et donc leur origine commune?

Certainement, ceci est le plus repandu et le plus profond comme soi-disant preuve de l'évolution. Et certainement on ne peut pas prétendre que les différents êtres soient issus chacun avec son ADN, chacun du non-vivant sans l'ADN, et par pure hazard aboutis à en avoir le même.

Mais un créateur commun explique autant qu'un ancêtre commun. L'intelligence artistique peut avoir économie artistique, même chez sa créature, l'homme. En plus, si un créateur commun les a tirés de la terre indépendamment les uns des autres, ça ôte le problème des différents nombres de chromosomes noté plus haut.

Voyons alors où ça continue:

Le pape reconnait aujourd'hui l'ADN comme support matériel pour ne pas dire matérialiste - ça n'irait pas avec support - de l'information génétique et les découvertes qui fondent le concept d'évolution.


De l'information génétique, d'accord, mais est-ce qu'il entend par là, le bon pape Benoît XVI "les découvertes qui fondent le concept de l'évolution"? Rappelons que Mendel n'était nullement évolutionniste. Selon Prêtre rejeté ouvrage autobiographique du père Bryan Houghton, Mendel était certaine époque, longue de 50 ans, "sur index" en France évolutionniste. Avec les chromosomes. Mais il ne peut y avoir "index" dans les sciences? Pas? Alors, d'où les dogmes et les pensées profondes que je viens de noter? Espérons juste que Benoît XVI ne partage pas le pire de Teilhard de Chardin!

Hans G. Lundahl
15/28 avril A. D. 2009
Carpentras

mardi 22 avril 2008

Speciations observed - but not in mammals.

Talkorigins claims speciation has been observed ... in plants and invertabrates. Exactly not in mammals who are exactly the type of animals where polyploidy is excluded. One event includes a diploid variety having as many chromosomes as a tetraploid would have - but noone observed it becoming diploid. The botanist found the new species among his plants:

5.1.1.1 Evening Primrose (Oenothera gigas)
While studying the genetics of the evening primrose, Oenothera lamarckiana, de Vries (1905) found an unusual variant among his plants. O. lamarckiana has a chromosome number of 2N = 14. The variant had a chromosome number of 2N = 28. He found that he was unable to breed this variant with O. lamarckiana. He named this new species O. gigas.


If he found it, how can he be sure it was offspring of his previously studied plants? Because, you see, if the new chromosome number had been not 2n=28, but 4n=28, it would have been a very simple case of polyploidy. Here the question is: how did the 28 start out as 4*7 and end up as 2*14? Also, it is not specified (ha ha) if he could breed Oenothera gigas at all. There is of course cloning ...

As for diverse chromosome numbers (a k a karyotypes) in mice, they do not make different species, it seems. Do not ask me when and where Mus musculus domesticus with 2n=40 and such with 2n=22 have crossbred, but they count as same species, hence they have the same Latin name. A new chromosomal race of the house mouse, Mus musculus domesticus ...

A want-to-read: creationist Jack Cuozzo's book about Neanderthal man.

Back to Update on Chromosome numbers which forms part of anti-Darwinism series (other issues top links).

lundi 21 avril 2008

Update on chromosome numbers

Talkorigins January 99 was the last look I had on Chromosome numbers, my earlier post depends on that info. Talkorigins July 05 adds information, if you scroll down a bit.

Yes, it seems that uneven chromosome numbers from different parents do occur in okapis, and that one chromosome from one may mate with two chromosomes from other: individuals with 22, 23 or 22.5 chromosome pairs (44, 46 or 45 chromosomes). No other mammals than okapis have been sighted so far*. The variations in number would still seem to come about by fission or - though not in this case - polyploidy. And apart frogs, it would seem that rodents too can be polyploid.**

I take the freedom to quote the last talkorigins, after he has answered on chromosome numbers:

Here's your budding tree.

common ancestor Chimp ancestor (single individual)
_____________________/
\
Human ancestor (single individual)


No, surely the branching involved entire breeding populations -- one band, or a few bands, of apes moving into a new territory far from the lands where other members of their species lived. As noted, at the branch point, both populations would have been apes of the same species; they wouldn't become different species until after the branch point, after geographical separation left them free to evolve in two different directions. Remember that, just as there was no "first French speaker" struggling to make himself understood in a nation of classical Latin speakers, so there was no "first human" or "first chimpanzee," but only a gradual change over many generations from the same ancestral species.***

Can you take it from there? What's the pathway? At this point, can the chimp ancestor still interbreed with either the common ancestor or with the human ancestor? It has to interbreed with something in order to produce more offspring after its own kind, so where does the partner come from?

Most evolutionists hold that most speciation events are "allopatric," meaning that they occur after the ancestral population has split into two groups that could interbreed if they met, but which no longer meet up. Afterwards, mutation, genetic drift, and selection to different environments gradually change the populations into different species. No particular mutation (unless you count polyploidy) is likely to produce a new species. A better (though still oversimplified) approach would be to think of a whole series of mutations, some beneficial, most neutral (but they still made us different from chimps), that each made the bearer a tiny bit more "human" (or, in the other lineage, a tiny bit more "chimp"). No single gene would have made its bearer much different from other members of his species, or unable to interbreed with them.

The scientist seems to have missed the point that "Zoe" had probably read my argument (with God knows how many intermediates) as implied in post 3 about Chromosome numbers: the whole point of her discussion was that there had to be a first individual with a different point of chromosome numbers from its parents and otherwise possible mating partners.

Though the okapi example and that of Przewalski's horse vs domestic horse interbreeding make the impossibility less heavy, it is at least a question of very rare occurrence and in mammals other than rodents polyploidy seems to have no rôle in augmenting chromosome numbers, and the fusions seem to have to have occurred very often if they are to account for all lessenings of chromosome numbers.

Of course I totally agree that single gene mutations do not as a rule interfere with interbreedability. There are lots of single genes where pa and ma were different, same applies to apples (anyone read the book Botany of Desire? It seems apples and men are species where you can count on sexually produced offspring being sensibly different from their origin and indeed unpredictable because of all chromosome differences and recombination possibilities): even in my late guinea pigs, a wavy haired white male, angora guinea pig, I think, a straight haired female golden aguti, a "curly" haired female called "Bianca Croce" with a white cross on darker colours (hence the name) produced varied and fertile offspring. But I am pretty sure they had the same chromosome numbers.

Hans Lundahl

Aix en Provence
Monday of Holy Week
8/21 April 2008

PS: Tried to notify the source of the second statement (the one here quoted), but his e-mail was outdated.

*and mice, sorry, another update will be due, here it is, along with evening primroses.

**Here is that quote:

polyploidy is duplication of the entire genome; plants speciate this way all the time, but it's rarer for animals (though there are strongly supported examples for frogs, rodents, and other vertebrates; presumably, they can't form a new species unless they can either reproduce parthenogenically, or unless polyploidy happens often enough that eventually it produces two members of the same species at the same time and place)
it is left unclear whether polyploid rodents would include only individuals or parthenogenic lines or any new species - note also that in polyploidy it is a question of all chromosomes, terefore same chromosomes doubled, whereas in doubling or halving of chromosomes other than doubling of all, the chance of two independently getting same modification is close to nil.

***But there was a first speaker for every change that differentiates Latin from French! There was a first speaker to drop the final nasalisation in "servum" (-um like -om in Portuguese bom) coming up with roughly servu (as in Sardinian/Corsican) or servo (as in Italian/Spanish), there was a first speaker to drop the vowel altogether (as in French/Occitan), and each first speaker had to make himself understood: and there was a first writer to decide not to write "ser(f)s, serf" as "servus, servum" but as "ser(f)s, serf", and he did it because he wanted it read and pronounced by people who did not have Francogallic Romance as a mother tongue when speaking on a certain occasion to people who did: the Occasion was the Oaths of Strasburg. The other side of the oath was written in passable phonetic approximation of Old High German, like Ripuarian Frankish or something. And passably phonetic approximations were again possible because Alcuin had come from York to teach the French to pronounce written "servus, servum" as, precisely "servus, servum" when speaking in Church. Other difference: we know people who spoke more or less Classic Latin gave rise to speakers of French, Occitan, Catalan, Castillian, Italian, Sardinian, Corsican: because we have the terminus a quo as well as the terminus ad quem (like the Gentle and magnanimous Frenchies that surround me here) under close observation by mainly themselves, including as writers, a capacity in which they sometimes survive their death. We know there was an Ausonius of Bourdeaux, to whom Classic Latin was essentially good grammar, and we know there was a Dante Alighieri of Florence to whom speaking Latin meant using the invention of speaking grammatically, an "invention" he describes in terms reminiscent of Esperanto - all the while using "si" "oc" and "oïl" to distinguish the languages he thinks of as real vernaculars (recognisable as Spanish/Italian, Provençal, French). And between them we know Alcuin and the oaths of Strassburg. Before Alcuin and after Ausonius we know that Gregory of Tours wrote bad Latin and Fredegar worse - as if they spoke Frenchily but wrote nearly Latin. After Alcuin we have the varied literary works in diverse Romance languages coming up, Song of Roland nearly two hundred years before Dante wrote Vita Nuova and Divina Commedia. We know all these individuals as we will never know Lucy - because either Lucy didn't write, or if she did her writing has not survived or if it did it is not put in relation to her sceleton. We know writers of old centuries as well as we know bloggers of foreign continents. At least as well as we know bloggers we have never written to or who have no possibility to write back. There are things we can never know about someone, because he is far away in place or time, because they are not directly there in the text, or because they have not been written down, but there are things we do know, because they have been written down. Lies cannot be totally excluded in all circumstances, but neither can those or other fakes in face-to-face intercourse. And what language someone writes when he writes himself is hard to fake. You may write a foreign language, but you may not write above your level in it, though you may sometimes improve it.